[Om2009] testing Release 3
mirko at openmoko.com
Mon May 11 10:05:07 CEST 2009
thanks for the kind words and the list of issues. We are trying to get
all of them reproduced, so that I can hunt them down :) If you can
reproduce the freezing issues or where the UI crashed, it would be great
if you could open a ticket on http://www.paroli-project.org/trac and
attach the paroli log and the fso log (/var/log/paroli.log and
Risto H. Kurppa wrote:
> Thanks for this new release, really happy to see that only a short
> time (a week?) after the previous there's already a new release with
> bugs fixed. Release early, release often, as they say :)
> I wrote some points below to show what's good, what I concider as
> bug/problem and points to discuss/wishlist/something. I'm sure some of
> it has already been discussed, some of it is just me not knowing how
> to use it (which can mean that it's not easy to use or a
> manual/something is needed) and so on. I'm happy to receive comments!
> + This actually makes FR a simple, very working phone!! (I actually
> got a 10 min call from my mum. In the end I asked and she said there's
> a small echo left)
> + ability to turn off PIN check & change pin! (I think it's the first
> distro that can do it :)
> + WLAN-tool
> + manual suspend
> + decent resume speed
> - some mess sometimes in the top of the scree
> - The button to 'go back / go to previous screen' keeps changing: In
> the menu there's a 'back' button (different size in different views)
> but in the people etc one has to know to press the top bar to go back.
> - Empty I/O shows an 'edit' button.. maybe it should be hidden and
> instead a text 'no logged events' could be shown?
good idea added to my list
> - keylock missing
think angus tried to find a suitable tool
> ¤ Would it be possible to add a SMS button in the 'People' -> contact
> view. Now clicking the number calls the user (intuitive? Why clicking
> the name nothing happens?). Maybe adding 'dial' and 'SMS' -buttons
> there just to make it clear.
The entries in people, messages and i/o should all be slidable (odd
spelling) to the right and show you an extra action, for people this is
a msgs button. unfortunately it seems to be not working for people, but
in the other lists it seems ok.
> - If one by accidentally presses 'Enter in the PIN input view, it just
> accepts it and doesn't ask for PIN again.
It does not return if you enter a wrong PIN?
> - wlan scan doesn't have a progress bar telling it's actually doing something
I am bound to what connman provides me. I don't get any progress sadly.
Should Paroli block any action until it found a network (which can be
bad in case there is none)? Or should it block until the scan is done (I
believe there is a signal from connman when it "completed" a scan)?
> - resume doesn't turn on the screen lights -> one knows it's resumed
> only by touching the screen
Will try to hook into the signal and set the back-light to 70.
> - GPRS settings: if one by accident clicks 'username', 'APN', or
> 'password' instead of Connect, one actually has to re-type it because
> the 'back' button doesn't work.
> - There's nothing (no text/button) telling one should click in the
> black area to get to phonebook to select recipient in 'msgs' -> '+' or
Should it get a grey fill when no number is entered? Or an icon?
> - Slow boot time (over 4min with Qi?)
> - the alsastatefile (kurppa.fi/freerunner/temp/gsmhandset.state_2009t3
> with Right PGA on control.63) is different from the latest 'working
> one' (with mic2) at
> ¤ How to connect to a hidden WLAN network? How about encryptions?
WPA,WEP and WPA2 should be handled correctly. This should also cover 90%
of all cases. I would love to have a more complete interface for wifi,
but am afraid I won't have the time. If there is anyone who wants to
adopt the whole wifi settings part (is only one py file) let me know and
I'll get him/her git access along with all the help I can provide.
The same goes for any settings option you want to work on. It should be
fairly easy to get into that part of paroli and a good way to get into
the rest as well ;)
> ¤ The numbers in the home view showing missed calls or received
> messages could be bigger/colorful/something or even say 'one missed
> call' or 'new SMS received'
> ¤ At some stage I saw the : in the time blinking, then it stopped. I
> think it either should blink or not but not keep changing what it does
> (without telling me what does it mean :)
Sorry, that is the old way of setting the time and alarm. I will disable
> ¤ Is there a way to enable illume from command line?
Angus answered that I believe, but why not use the setting in Display -
> profile in paroli settings?
> ¤ Icon that's shown before GSM network registration doesn't tell me
> anything. What does it actually represent?
It is supposed to mean not connected ;)
> ¤ The only place where I was able to find colors was the yellow flash
> in the battery icon when recharging. Using colors in other places too
> would maybe do it easier to use?
> ¤ With hundreds of phone numbers it'd be great to be able to type at
> least the first letter, or two-three to be able to find the
Agreed search function would be nice...no sure how to implement that.
> ¤ I got many 'can't init topbar/wlan/...' -messages telling that
> something failed (only on the first start)
Some services are only usable after the second boot. Rule of thumb,
always boot Om2009 twice after flashing ;)
> ¤ The date doesn't need the | -bars in the home view: it's | Sunday,
> May 10, 2009 | - the bars just make it more difficult to read
> ¤ Does paroli (already / in the future?) support icons in the menus?
> Either so that there would be a icon grid or like now but every line
> would have a small icon just to make it easier to use
> ¤ GPRS settings: Should the password be hidden? (I don't know if
> anyone is really interested in GPRS passwords..)
Yeah, I don't think there is too many secrets about that, anyone any
objections to showing it?
> ¤ GPRS settings: maybe APN should be 'internet' by default, I think
> it's the most common APN?
> ¤ GPRS settings: I'd recommend reordering the items so that the
> connect would be first or last in the list.
I will redo parts of the settings app and classes so that ordering is
possible and meant to ask the list which order is most useful :)
> ¤ I/O really doesn't tell for a normal people that it's actually the call log..
> ¤ Msgs could be replaced with SMS, if something short has to be used
> ¤ Tele also doesn't make sense, I'd suggest using 'Dialer'
> ¤ How do I use the alarm? How do I change the time when to alert?
Not quite there yet ;)
> ¤ Maybe also reordering the main menu so that the phone log would not
> be the first one?
Falls into the "fix later" category, but is on my list :)
> ¤ At some stage my FR just decided not to resume any more
> ¤ After the 10min call the UI died, I wasn't able to press any
> buttons, nothing happened. Then after waiting some minutes it started
> running again. Still the top left shows '100' instead of default or
Got logs for that one?
Thanks again for your thorough review this really helps.
More information about the community