joerg at openmoko.org
Fri Aug 29 17:54:23 CEST 2008
Am Fr 29. August 2008 schrieb Uwe Klein:
> On 8/29/08, Andy Green <andy at openmoko.com> wrote:
> > Fair enough, I could tell you it won't survive 12V on USB port. Nor
> > will any other USB device I heard of, I think it is OK.
> There are these nice little (Zehner) diodes that are designed
> to fail into a shorted mode.
> TransZorb, TranSil ....
> Gives protection against overvoltage and inverted supply.
Nope, Tranzorb won't help here because the energy this component had to absorb
is too high, so it would burn out. Transzorbs are for ESD surge suppression
But we already found a decent way to protect USB of GTA03 with a replacement
for U4905 (GTA02-schematics), which gives OVP up to 25V continuous. Component
cost around +/-zero, compared to original design :-). I'm happy with that!
For GTA02 though I would recommend to strictly avoid connecting it to *any*
source with even transients >5.5V, as this is ABSOLUTE maximum of PCF50633
At least I tell you now, not "could tell you..." ;-)
Also I tell you now there are very few universal power supplies of the type
you might use with powered USB-hubs (barrel connector), that guarantee a
voltage of within +/-10% of selected output voltage under all operation
conditions, like e.g. sudden switchoff of 1A-charging mode.
However meanwhile main rant here seems to be about additional cost for a
~$0.05 diode to clamp reverse voltage and trip the polyfuse we have in new
GTA03 design. Obviously there is a notion customer wouldn't like to pay this
price for increased ruggedness of USB-power input. Also there have been
objections about the safety of such a design, not taking in account that it
can not be less safe than what we had originally.
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Size: 194 bytes
Desc: This is a digitally signed message part.
Url : http://lists.openmoko.org/pipermail/hardware/attachments/20080829/2ddefe42/attachment-0001.pgp
More information about the hardware