4.4.2 quick feedback, was: Re: QT Extended version 4.4.2 release is out!

[Lorn Potter]

On Sat November 1 2008 7:31:31 am Warren Baird wrote:
> On Fri, Oct 31, 2008 at 2:13 PM, Johny Tenfinger <seba.dos1 at gmail.com>wrote:
> > Suspend/resume problems are AFAIK kernel issues, reporting it on Qt
> > Extended topics aren't usefull...
>
> I'm not sure I agree.   In QT Extended  4.4.1 the phone would reliably wake
> up from suspend on a phone call or SMS - in 4.4.2 it doesn't.   That makes
> it a QT Extended issue.

It's not a Qt Extended issue. If you would put 4.4.2 on the rootfs that came 
with 4.4.1, you would most likely not see this suspend problem.

Qt Extended has nothing to do with how a phone suspends other than telling it 
when to suspend itself, or how the device wakes up. The modem is responsible 
for waking up the phone up when there is an incoming call or message.

But the appearance is that Qt Extended 4.4.2 has a suspend problem.

>
> I don't particularly care whether the underlying problem is that QT has
> changed the kernel between the two version, or they've changed a config
> setting that breaks this - it's a problem introduced in the new version of
> QT Extended...
>
> And, unfortunately, it makes the FR with QT Extended totally useless as a
> phone - If you disable suspend the battery life is too short, and if you
> enable suspend you miss your phone calls.
>
> *sigh*
>
> Warren

-- 
Lorn 'ljp' Potter
Software Engineer, Systems Group, Qt Software, Nokia Pty Ltd