Openmoko on Design
wyvern at phoenixphamily.com
Tue Jul 29 00:40:12 CEST 2008
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
~ I don't need a major design statement for my phone...I just want
a (mostly) working phone. There is a point where "taking one more thing
away" doesn't make it simpler any longer, it makes it hard to figure
out/work on. Not having a terminal in ASU ( the general style of which I
like) and taking the manual keyboard switch out of ASU (which actually
WORKS as opposed to the automatic pop up which doesn't) were bad ideas ,
at least for as long as this thing is going to be in pre-release. I
could understand it in a general release, but the people who have it now
are EXACTLY the kind of people who would whip it out and noodle around
with the terminal during lunch break if they could. I know I
would......or if you HAVE to leave them out could someone post easy to
follow directions to replace them in the wiki somewhere?? For those of
us not gifted with totally amazing programming skills?
~ Oh, and my general opinion is, if there is no bitching, no drama
and no complaints...if no one stirs the shit and throws tantrums-it
ain't Open Source. So get used to it everyone..if NONE of it was
happening, guess what? We'd all be working for (shudder) Microsoft or
~ Lisa Waddell
~ :) Queen of the Drama Zone
Sean Moss-Pultz wrote:
| Dear Community
| Many people seem to expect an explanation of "design" from Openmoko.
This isn't going to happen. At least not today. Design isn't something
static that I can stop and say here is exactly what Openmoko wants. 1+1
= 2. We try not to talk so much about features or design styles of
future products. For the simple reason that we’re not so sure what they
will look like ourselves. Design, for us, is the process in which we
start by pursuing a few essential ideas and allow for the final result
to come into being. Notice that I am not talking about moving pixels.
Nor I'm not talking about colors or fonts. Design, in my opinion, is not
about technical skill. It's about personal struggle. It's the process by
which you relentlessly force yourself to focus on exposing your
essential ideas. This cannot be patched and merged like source codes.
Imagine Malevich and Monet each painting half of the same painting. The
result would surely depress them both. Being open doesn't mean we put
the essential ideas behind each product to a public vote. Being open
means we provide you with the tools to change our decisions.
| Like anything highly creative, design is always highly subjective.
Even if I would explain the essential ideas of our products to everyone,
they would not make sense in the way I want them to. Because you are
only seeing one part of a very intricate long-term plan. You would need
to work with us, full time, for many months before Openmoko's vision
would really make sense. I can only show you the tangible pieces --
products. Our company is open. You are always invited into this space.
Don't forget you are watching serious people work their ass' off. We are
mechanics and will certainly yell, "Fuck!" when we smash our fingers or
break things. All engineering is public from day one. It is humanly
impossible for us not to show you things that are unfinished,
inaccurate, flawed, and even self-destructive at times. But we have
faith in what we're doing. Openness is our foundation. It's not a
marketing buzzword. So my only question for you is, "Do you want to
watch, or help?". Because if you want to just stand around and criticize
our work, I will have to ask you to leave the shop. People are working
here. We're trying to "Free your Phone". Stop bashing things like ASU.
This is our work and we are in the earliest of stages. We want to share
it with you. Understand that we are not even close to satisfied with it
in its current state. But we can see the direction and we love how it's
coming together. This is the design process in full effect.
| Think of our products as museums. We're building the environment. Each
one different from the next. You'll get all the free art supplies you
could imagine because we want you to add your own meaning. You choose:
consume, create, or both. Either way you create your own meaning. It's
about you. Our design is more like non-design. We try to "remove"
anything obvious. And focus on what's meaningful. We're not trying to
launch a carefully crafted message with a bling-filled user interface.
We're building an empty vessel for you to fill with your ideas. We focus
on making products that are open and simple. Only products that are open
can grow as you grow. Only something simple can be used by everyone.
| My mom can install Firefox plugins. Can your mom personalize your
| Like Will already said, by removing a manual keyboard button we are
forced to self-organize using the resources in our environment.
Resources such as our wiki and our Installer are still badly broken. We
need to fix these. We need to make them accessible for "normal people".
Every element "removed" is a chance to organize information in ways that
are meaningful for others. Whether you like our design or not isn't even
the question. You have all the tools you could possibly want to change it.
| At Openmoko, we're trying as hard as we can to not over design. Could
you imagine walking into a museum where the museum itself looked better
than the artwork? We're trying to give you the environment to
self-organize. Your code. Your ideas. Your emotions. And then share them
back with others. The entire point of our "Installer" is to provide a
simple way to bring the excitement and energy of our community into the
Neos of normal people. Why else would we invest so much time and money
into things like our framework? Or even the little things like opening
our CAD files and our schematics? We're building you a museum to
showcase the wonderful diversity of this community. It's a foundation
for you to stand on. We want your applications. Your ideas in the form
of packages of what the buttons can do. Change anything you want to our
interface and we will gladly deliver it to everyone. Your music for
sound events. Your themes. Speak with your work, not so much with your
emails. Let's organize the best parts of mobile FOSS as packages easily
installable for the world. We're not going to build yet another App Store.
| We must end these unproductive arguments about whose design ideas are
better. Should the keyboard be manual or automatic -- this so misses the
point of Openmoko! The "killer app" of tomorrow is not going to be
software or some hardware device. It's going to be the social practices
they make possible.
| We each have our own ways of understanding and making meanings. You
are free to create your own meanings. Organize your ideas into our wiki
and our Installer. Make a package that somebody can easily install for a
manual keyboard. Show people the power of open. Let them make their own
meanings. For if we cannot organize our ideas in ways non-developers can
understand, why even bother? Why struggle so hard to make totally open
devices when you can already download thousands of random hacks and
applications for an iPhone?
| This is Openmoko. We are different. We are open to life. We are never
closed, perfect or complete. We embrace diversity. Open means we are
free to change the fundamental way information is processed in the
mobile world. Let's do this!
| Now is the time for our work to speak for itself. I'm out of words.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.4-svn0 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with SUSE - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the community